Enter your zip to
find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

When Is It Time To Replace Gutters?

When is it time for a gutter replacement? Learn about when to replace your gutter system to avoid costly damage to your home.

Are you doing a gutters project?

Modernize can pair you with three to four pros in your area, so you can compare options and save time and money.

Gutters often get overlooked by homeowners, but they play a crucial role in any house. Faulty gutters can cause serious damage if homeowners leave them untreated. Understanding common signs can help you detect whether you need a gutter replacement before problems arise.

Regularly checking your entire gutter system for signs of damage can help you avoid future headaches and costly expenses. While some damage might be visible on dry days, inspecting for possible gutter replacement needs during rainy weather is essential, as some signs become more noticeable.

Gutters in a rainstorm

When is it Time for a Gutter Replacement?

Here are nine main signs that indicate your home needs a gutter replacement or gutter repair

1. Cracking

A cracked gutter drains water out and defeats the purpose of your drainage system. You can repair a small crack or two individually, but they may signal a larger problem. Several serious cracks indicate that you need a gutter replacement.

2. Rust

A few spots of rust aren’t a major concern. Gutters are designed to move water, and minimal rust damage can be repaired. However, if you see more than a couple of patches or any large impacted areas, this may indicate a bigger issue that requires a more extensive project. Connect with a professional sooner rather than later to determine if the rust on your gutter system needs replacement.

3. Leaky or Separated Seals

Gutters remain most vulnerable at the seams where different sections attach. Inspect these areas closely for leaks, separations, or sags to ensure the seals stay intact.

A properly functioning gutter system funnels water toward downspouts. Water should not spill through the gutters near the roof.

Check your gutters during a rainstorm to ensure they funnel water downwards and away from your home’s base. If your gutters leak or clog and you don’t address this issue promptly, water can seep into your home and cause damage.

4. Paint Damage

Water often poses a threat to your home! Paint bubbles or peeling on your siding likely result from water damage, often caused by a faulty gutter system.

If you see an area with damaged paint, inspect the condition of the nearest gutter and look for any damage. If you’re unsure whether the gutters cause the siding damage, consult a professional for an expert’s opinion.

5. Rotting

Similar to paint damage, water from a broken gutter system can rot siding, window sills, or door frames. Wood siding is especially prone to rotting from damaged gutters. Prevent additional siding replacement projects by proactively repairing your gutter system.

6. Mold or Mildew

Have you ever noticed a patch of green or black discoloration on a home? A damaged gutter system may fail to move water away from the home’s exterior. If you find mold or mildew in a previously dry area, ill-functioning gutters might be the cause.

Find the Right Contractor for Your Gutters Project

Whether you’re ready to begin your project now or need some expert advice, our network of contractors are here to help. With a few simple questions, we’ll find the best local professionals for you

7. Roof Separation

Ensure your gutters and roof attach properly to maximize effectiveness. Occasionally, fasteners connecting the two can become loose or damaged and require simple replacement. If the problem persists, check the fascia boards connecting the gutter and roof for signs of rot. If you find rot, you will likely need a gutter replacement.

8. Sagging

If sections of your gutters sag, pooling water can occur. This pooling leads to spill-overs and possibly cracks or separation. You might also notice unexpected landscaping damage after rain or unusual flooding, which may indicate sagging gutters.

9. Flooded Basements

When water accumulates in areas where it shouldn’t, it can cause extensive damage to your basement or foundation if you allow it to continue. Address this serious issue immediately upon discovery.

Avoiding Gutter Damage

It is worth noting that gutter replacement projects are typically much more affordable compared to fixing the damage that occurs when they are neglected. However, all of this can be avoided by being proactive and caring for your gutters routinely.

Cleaning gutters isn’t the most exciting task for homeowners, but it can help alleviate future problems. Thorough cleaning and maintenance about twice per year should help you maintain a properly working gutter system and allow you to identify any issues that might require repair or a full gutter replacement.

Modernize recommends performing routine maintenance and cleaning in the spring and fall. It is also important to prep your gutter system ahead of any anticipated inclement weather or rainfall to ensure it is able to do its job properly.

Next Steps

If you notice any of the above signs of gutter damage or have an aging system, you’ll want to speak with a gutter contractor to help you determine the best course of action to remedy the situation. The good news is that a new gutter system can last for decades if properly maintained in most conditions. Gutter installations are affordable projects, and you have an assortment of options for a project that best fits your budget.

If you are preparing for a gutter replacement project, become familiar with what to expect during the gutter installation. You can also learn how to compare gutter replacement quotes to choose a professional that fits your needs and budget.

Speak with the professionals at Modernize today to get connected with a trusted gutter contractor in your area to install a gutter system that protects your family and home from the elements.

Find the Right Contractor for Your Gutters Project

Whether you’re ready to begin your project now or need some expert advice, our network of contractors are here to help. With a few simple questions, we’ll find the best local professionals for you

Reviews from Real Homeowners

About Us

Welcome to Homeowner Resources! We are the Modernize blog. Modernize pairs more than 3 million homeowners a year with pre-vetted contractors in their area. This blog started because we believe homeowners should know everything about their homes, from how their HVAC works to which front door colors they might love. On Homeowner Resources, you can find information on every part of your home, right down to how you can negotiate with contractors to get the best price. Here's more about the blog.

Need a contractor? Learn more about how Modernize finds the right pro for you.